"Educating" a Preschooler


I will say that I was all about early academics when I first contemplated homeschooling. My husband was doing graduate work in gifted education, and that was a topic of interest for me as well. I observed and taught many gifted children and saw what they could do. (And I knew, of course, that my children would be gifted too.) Of course one must accelerate the academics so as not to hold back a talented student.

I hear more questions about what to teach to preschoolers than about anything else. (Maybe it’s because young mothers are the ones who read blogs about homeschooling!) Anyway, this has been on my mind of late, and I hope I can communicate what I’ve been feeling.
We often hear that little children are “sponges.” They have an amazing capacity for learning before age five. Shouldn’t we capitalize on this ability and help them get ahead in the world? But how do you define “ahead”? Is it all about the three R’s? What are your priorities for your children? What do you think makes a successful adult?

But I also saw that these gifted children were CHILDREN. They laughed at the same silly jokes that would make any child laugh. Some were incredibly disciplined, but they were still learning how to make good choices. All of them needed their parents nearby.

My priorities began to change as my own children came along. I moved from a world of “high grades and test scores are everything” and “you can go as far as you want, if you’re smart enough” to a world of just enjoying the sweet smell of a baby and wanting to keep my little ones close (usually). That high-pressure, competitive world—though I sometimes missed it—was no longer my main goal. I also wanted my children to feel secure, to have deep spiritual roots, to grow strong and healthy in every way. I saw homeschooling not only as a way to maintain high academic standards, but as a way to protect my children from bad influences which could jeopardize these other priorities.

What I finally realized is that LIFE is the curriculum for a young child (and hopefully that will continue to some extent as he grows older). Ideally, the preschool years should be spent around Mom and Dad, observing them and helping them as soon as the child is able. This is an education in how a family works and how a home is run. The family celebrates the seasons and holidays, and the child learns about his culture. The family visits friends and relatives, and the child learns how to get along with other people. I wonder how different our society would be today if children got more of this education?

The child plays outside where big-muscle movements stimulate his brain and make his body strong. What his body and brain need most--especially in the preschool years--are good food, plenty of movement, and ample sleep (12-14 hours every day).

Daddy tells stories at bedtime. The child wants the same stories over and over—and that is also a part of his education. Daddy never speaks in baby-talk though, so the child learns rich use of his language. He knows the stories so well that he can fill in those wonderful-sounding words even when Daddy misses them.

Mommy sings songs while she makes the meals. She sings about what she’s doing or just sings songs that make everyone feel happy. Sometimes she makes up little rhymes when the child has a question. (You don’t have to be a poet! One of D’s favorites was a silly song that went “When the ground shakes, it’s called an earthquake. Doodly doodly doo.”)

Of course the child will ask lots of questions and will want to learn things, especially if he has older siblings that are doing them. If he wants to know how to write his name, he should be shown his name—but not asked to learn the alphabet. When he asks about numbers, they can be explained—but with concrete objects, not with symbols. This time of life is more about a child observing his world than about memorizing facts. If there are older children in his family, the child probably “does school” with them, but his work consists of modeling with clay, knitting with his fingers, or building towers with the math manipulatives.

Two of my children taught themselves to read in their preschool years, but one didn’t read until he was ten years old. That gave him a slower start, but didn’t seem to make a difference by age 12. Did you know that research (Bloom, University of Chicago) has shown that an entire K-12 curriculum can be taught to an older student in just nine months? THERE IS NO RUSH! There is plenty of time for the academics, but only a few short years of carefree, light-hearted, imagination-filled childhood. As my dear Marsha Johnson puts it, “You are not filling up a bucket. You are lighting a fire.”

The World will tell you otherwise. You will be pressured—by friends, perhaps by family, even by the government—to help your precious little ones “get ahead” (of what?). Please take some time to write down your priorities for your children—both long- and short-term. Ponder and pray about what is needed to help your children achieve those goals. Then don’t be swayed by others who don’t know your family as well as you do. Your educational choices may be different than mine, but I hope they will include much more than academics.

My Four- (or Five- or Six-) Year Plan

(aka "Scope and Sequence")
When all my children were young, our homeschool lessons were totally interest-based. I didn’t really have an over-all plan. As Je got closer to high school, however, I got more organized. I decided to follow my state’s requirements for high school graduation, although homeschoolers don’t earn a state-recognized high school diploma. College entrance requirements tend to match (or exceed) the high school guidelines—so we needed to follow them.

All of my children do math and language arts at their individual levels each year, but our social studies and science we do together. My state requires two years of high school science, but exact courses aren’t specified so we can follow our interests. It’s the social studies requirements that are more detailed, and so I plan my years around those guidelines.

*We spend a year on ancient history (of the Western world)—Mesopotamia, Egypt, Greece, Rome.
*Our next year of world history covers mostly the Middle Ages and Renaissance.
*When we have time (depending on who’s in high school and what they still need), we study other parts of the world—the Orient, the Arctic, or Africa, for example
*We begin U.S. history, beginning with exploration of the New World and including a significant unit on the U.S. Constitution.
*Whenever we get to the Westward Expansion, we do a semester of Washington state history. Then we finish U.S. history, up to the present.
And start over!

Plannning for Fall

It’s summer vacation :o) and I’m having fun planning for the coming year.
I asked each of my children what they want to learn about (astronomy, nutrition, disease, plants, herbal medicine). I looked at Steiner’s themes for my second grader (fables and saints). And I considered my general “scope and sequence,” which has us studying ancient history this year.
All I’m doing at this point is blocking out the units we will study for each month. I’ll plan in more detail when I actually get there. Here’s how it has come together:
SEPTEMBER
Most of our time will be spent with canning and dehydrating, so we call it our harvest unit. Also, while the weather is still nice, we’ll go to nearby state parks where we’ll draw in our new nature journals (a back-to-school gift). We’ll study astronomy, which will continue through the year as we learn about various ancient cultures and their views of the sky. It’s a good time to celebrate the 40th anniversary of men on the moon!
The last week of the month we’ll celebrate St. Michael’s day (the 29th). I’m thinking the dragon would be a good constellation to learn first….
OCTOBER
We’ll study Mesopotamia / Babylon. Scripture equates Babylon with worldliness, so we’ll spend some time with what it means to separate ourselves from the world.
D will be hearing stories about St. Francis of Assisi (his day is October 4th), who renounced worldliness to serve God.
NOVEMBER
L and N will be studying Egypt, so I’ll make up related stories for D to review his math operations and learn place value. I guess the math gnomes will visit the Nile River!
St. Martin’s day is November 11th.
DECEMBER
We’ll catch up on any loose ends, celebrate St. Lucia day, the winter solstice, and Christmas! We like to relax and enjoy this season.
JANUARY
We’ll study Greece. D will be learning fables from the Greek story teller Aesop. I’ll introduce Hippocrates, in preparation for our next unit. We’ll definitely tie in astronomy, because the Greeks knew a lot about the heavens.
FEBRUARY
We’ll learn about nutrition and disease. This should make for some interesting stories for teaching D about mathematical equations!
MARCH
L and N will learn about Rome. I will choose stories of 8 more “saints” to tell to Daniel, and he’ll make a reading book.
APRIL
N and L will have a unit on health and healing herbs. D will be hearing more fables, so I’ll choose some about plants.
MAY
We’ll all be helping with the vegetable garden, so we will study more botony. D will learn about Northwest animals, as well as plants.
JUNE
We may do a short unit on marine science. We often like to go visit our favorite tide pools for the low tide this time of year. I’ll see how we’re doing by next June!
Meanwhile, I’m looking forward to a really fun year (but enjoying every leisurely minute of summer too).

More Waldorf Principles--Steiner's Themes

I have mentioned that the Waldorf curriculum “speaks” to a child at his level. Let me tell you what that means. Language arts, math, and social studies are all taught through stories. But there are specific stories for each age group:

A first grader is rapidly changing and growing physically. He is losing his baby teeth. He is becoming more coordinated. All of his energy has been going to his physical body rather than to his intellect. He is still more in his imagination than in the “real world.” So he is told fairy tales—simple, archetypal stories where there are powerful Kings, where wickedness is punished, and where there may even be a little magic.

A second grader is learning to make decisions for himself as he approaches the age of accountability. Thus, his curriculum includes stories of “saints” and other revered people so he can see what GOOD is. And he also learns fables—to show him how to make choices between right and wrong, and that every choice has consequences.

A third grader is facing what Steiner called the “nine-year change,” and it can be traumatic. So he studies the Old Testament (even if it is not part of his religion) because its history parallels his inner journey. The expulsion from Eden, the slavery in Egypt, the wandering in the wilderness…over and over the Hebrew people fail, yet they are loved by a generous God who always gives them another chance and guides them to the Promised Land.

A fourth grader is discovering who he is and what the world has to offer. He hears stories about what it means to be human, to be different than the other animals. And he learns of Norse mythology, which is all about nines (his age). These ancient stories don’t always end happily: they are full of mischief and ambivalence, just like the real world.

I appreciate the way that each curriculum doesn’t just teach facts, but actually nourishes the child. Although I don’t follow Steiner’s themes up through grade 12, I like to use them at least in these early years.

Disclaimer...

I’ve spent a lot of time on this blog talking about Waldorf education. I feel it is the best educational model I have seen, especially for a classroom environment. I love the fact that it is protective of childhood and that it follows life’s cycles and rhythms. Each element of the curriculum “speaks” to a child at his level. The arts and the handwork are healing and inspiring. But I don’t DO all of it at my house.

My biggest hang-up involves how to teach multiple topics—specifically science and history--to multiple children. All Waldorf homeschoolers have this challenge, but there is a reason why I’m not really willing to try others’ solutions. Ask any of my children, and they will tell you that our read-alouds (our family unit studies) are/were their favorite part of homeschool. How can I take that away to teach the age-appropriate topics? I haven’t figured it out.

So, when I talk about what we’re doing in our homeschool, you’ll notice that I’m not following a strictly Waldorf curriculum. We make music and work with our hands, but we also study famous artists and composers the Charlotte Mason way. We joyfully celebrate many holidays and festivals, but we don’t always do circle time. I always try to teach “whole to parts.” But we study science and history together as a family. I have tried to learn the principles that make Waldorf education what it is, but I don’t feel bound to other people’s views of what the details must be. I seek inspiration for the current needs of my children, and go with that. Isn’t that what homeschooling’s all about?

There are many wonderful and inspiring websites and blogs where you can learn about Waldorf education. Here, though, you’ll find more of a hodge-podge. Just thought you should know….

Saxon? or Something Else?--My Opinions on Options for Homeschool Math

When I started homeschooling, there weren’t many math curricula to choose from; most people I knew used Saxon. I started out that way, but I have tried many different things over the years. Here are the pros and cons of the different programs our family has used. Though your children will have different needs from my children, I hope this will help you in your search for a good “fit” for your family.
And here’s the punchline (in case you don’t want to read through my whole review to get it): I prefer living books--with enrichment from various sources as needed--for the elementary years, then MUS for secondary students.

Saxon (I haven’t used the DVD's, only the books)
Saxon is thorough. There is lots of repetition and lots of drill. So students using Saxon usually test well. The explanations are pretty good, so students can learn independently.
What I don't like about Saxon books is that they tell how to do the math, but not why. This isn't too bad in the lower level books, but gets really obnoxious by Algebra II. Some of my kids weren't bothered, but others hated it.

traditional textbooks
Obviously I can't cover every publisher's math books, but I've had a pretty good experience with the ones I've seen and used. One advantage is that they're colorful. (Some of my kids had a hard time with Saxon's lack of color.) But they are, of course, a "parts to whole" approach--so I think there are better options.

MathUSee (MUS)
Math U See has the best explanations I have seen of why we do math a certain way. Often it takes the "long way around" a topic in order to help the student see the why before showing the shortcut.
Another advantage of MUS: Steve Demme is funny! I have caught my reluctant math students smiling as they watched the DVD's.
I love the basic manipulatives and the fraction manipulatives. We use the algebra manipulatives only rarely.
A disadvantage of the elementary MUS levels is that they spend a whole year focused on one topic (while reviewing other topics, of course). I got the Gamma level when L was struggling with multiplication. It helped her, but spending a whole year on multiplication would have been way too much.
I like the secondary levels a lot, especially with the Honors problems added.

Life of Fred (See my previous post.)
We have only used Fred's Beginning Algebra, and it was very engaging. It is whole to parts, but I feel there is not always enough explanation. We used it along with MUS.

Miquon Math (uses Cuisinaire rods)
This is a curriculum for grades 1-3 only. You do need the teacher's book, because it has fantastic explanations and additional activities.
Miquon is pretty structured, but I like to pick and choose from the wide variety of activities. Even though it is workbook-style, the pages seem appealing to kids.

Cuisinaire books
These are not a specific sequence of books, but just books on a variety of topics, published by the same people who make the rods. Not only are there books for the basic arithmetic operations, but spatial problem solving, perimeter & area, and others.
One thing I do not like is that Cuisinaire equates a color with a number (e.g. add brown + green). I prefer the MUS manipulatives where marks on the block show what number it stands for. However, there is something nice about the wooden rods. D's math gnomes love to use them for all kinds of problems.

living books and activities
One of my favorite math resources is livingmath.net. This website has suggestions for living books about math (as well as lots of other very cool ideas and even lesson plans). It is totally "whole to parts" and I believe this type of math education is really plenty for the youngest children. As children get older, they can do games or other activities to drill the math facts, and don't really need texts at all.
Even in later years, "living math" is good for review and building interest. Though I wish we could have tried all of the recommended books, our favorites of what we have tried are the "Murderous Maths" series, certain of the "Math Start" series, the "Sir Cumference" books, and the game Mythmatical Battles (a card game using the times tables). Last, but not least, I love the DVD Donald Duck in Mathemagic Land.

Of course we have our math gnomes and other Waldorf-inspired activities. I'm not sure where to categorize them, but they are an important part of math classes at our house. If you need help with more ideas for those, look at alittlegardenflower.com.

Teaching math has probably been the most challenging part of my homeschool journey, but these days there are lots of resources to help.